Farm Industry News Blog

Dealing with food labels

GMO labeling talk will go on - but what are food labels meant to do?

The food label is apparently the silver bullet of the future. It's going to save us from GMOs…really?

So why is a technology editor going off on food labels? Our industry coverage here at Farm Industry News is to look at both the hardware (equipment) and software (seed tech, crop protection) of the industry and GMOs fit right in. And this debate over food labels will impact your farm in one way or another.

We have a lot of information on those food labels now, not sure how "may contain GMO ingredients" is going to help. I read food labels now more than ever - that's what a new cardiac stent will do for you (go technology!) And I want that food label to tell me what's there, period.

Would I care if that label added: "This product contains corn starch derived from a strain of corn that has been modified to protect itself from corn rootworms using Agrisure Duracade? Herculex RW?" I probably wouldn't but you can see how getting truly specific would actually not help anyone.

And what about the safety questions, a blogger on Forbes.com recently noted that major media outlets pretty much said "science has left the building" on the debate. It's an interesting look at how the Vermont GMO labeling law is being covered.

Sure, consumers want to know what's in their food. I get that, I do too. But what is GMO content? If the corn starch comes from GMO corn - and most does - is that a worry? What should the label say: "Made with GMO ingredients." I'm not sure that's helpful.

As someone who follows technology a lot, and has been around biotech since 1990 (I have colleagues who have covered it longer than that) I don't fear it. We've been researching this precision form of plant enhancement for decades and just because something just came to market doesn't mean it popped up like a mushroom on a warm day; this is technology that has been fine-tuned, researched for many years and has proven to do as advertised.

(Note to commenters - and I hope you'll comment - don't mix up a worry about resistant weeds with food labeling. It's frankly not the same issue.)

So back to that food label. I want the label to tell me what's in the food. Not how it was made. The U.S. Food and Drug Administration food label lists what's in there, nothing more. And that's as it should be.

Some might differ with me but let me give you one example. Take soybean oil. Through the crush process, the DNA in that oil is long gone - there's no DNA in soybean oil period, which means there is no GMO content in soybean oil.

However, labeling advocates may support labeling soybean oil as a GMO product because the beans where the oil originated had GMO technology. If you label soybean oil - which has no actual GMO-derived content - because of its association with the source. That's not a food label that makes sense. No actual GMO content, no actual note on the label. Of course, I'm not sure how this labeling issue will finally show up, but you can see how complex it is.

It appears FDA is still balking at the need for a national label, though Congress is moving ahead with an initiative to label foods, in part to stop a potential tide of state-based labels that make interstate commerce a nightmare. But when you apply science (no DNA in soybean oil) it gets murkier, but then again it's not like labeling proponents are using science as their credo.

Vermont's new GMO labeling law will push the issue. Chances are it'll have a run through the courts before implementation. The bill is worth reading if you want to understand the issues brought up in the debate.

Perhaps there is a way to label this content. For the GMO haters it's their way to kill the tech, though in the long run there are a lot of good things that can come from advancements here - golden rice anyone?

Recently the Council for Agricultural Science & Technology released it's look at the GMO labeling issue, and the folks at Feedstuff Foodlink offer an interesting look at the issues raised. A food label should tell me what's in the food. Specificity may help; more likely it's just going to add more confusion at a time when FDA is already talking about big changes to the label.

It is sound science that'll feed 9 billion plus people by 2050, not a food label or a fight against tech that can boost yields and enhance food quality. The debate rages on.

Want to keep up on the latest ag technology updates? Subscribe to Farm Industry News Now e-newsletter to get the latest news and more straight to your inbox twice weekly.

Discuss this Blog Entry 7

on May 23, 2014

Great blog and I love what you have to say coco palms | coco palms pasir ris and I think I will tweet this out to my friends so they can check it out as well. I like what you have to say

on Sep 20, 2014

This article gives the light in which we can observe the reality. This is very nice one and gives in depth information. This content is very useful for young generation and i hope it is providing alot of knowledge to us. Somanabolic Muscle Maximizer Reviews

on Jun 8, 2014

This is great saying bro, i wish all the best for you

Protein foods

high protein vegetarian foods

on Jun 18, 2014

David Beckham's line of underwear for H&M has got competition - from another David who can also pull a strong pose in a pair of briefs. Step http://www.planbois.it/helps.aspx forward David Gandy, who Marks & Spencer are referring to as 'the world's only male supermodel'. The high street retailer's new protégée is designing a 28-piece collection of underwear and sleepwear which will go on sale in September.

The 34-year-old Dolce & Gabbana favourite is the face of the retailer's M&S Collection line, and said he was "delighted" to take the union to a creative level. It's the first time that I've been involved with the design and creation of a collection and I've thoroughly enjoyed every minute of it," commented the Essex native. "I've been keen to focus on the detail, from the quality of materials and everyday comfort and fit, to style so that they are at the heart of each piece and form the basic essentials of the range.

The range, named David Gandy for Autograph, follows in the footsteps of British model Rosie Huntington-Whiteley, who launched her Rosie for Autograph line of lingerie in August 2012. Huntington-Whiteley's debut was the street retailer's fastest-selling lingerie collection, so she has set the bar high for Gandy. Each year worldwide we sell over 14 million singles of men's underwear" remarked Scott Fyfe, director of menswear for M&S. "This collaboration brings together our market leading expertise with David's unique viewpoint and eye for design and finishing, developed during his hugely successful career as a top male model.

Naturally, Gandy will be http://www.abmcompany.com/faq.aspx stepping in to model his wares and a launch event will take place in London on September 18. The collection will be rolled out across 274 stores nationally as well in 100 Marks & Spencer stores across the world.

on Aug 15, 2014

It is especially good for rural areas because it is great on the details
Thanks for this post, it's really useful
I've just decided to create a blog . , www.clearvisionreview.blogspot.com
how to cure Nearsightedness,how to avoid Effects Corrective Lenses,the blurry vision,Eye Surgery,how get rid of Glasses, www.clearvisionreview.blogspot.com
how could quickly and naturally restore the vision,
how to avoid lasik surgery ,Eye Disease,Easy Clear Vision Review,You'll find plenty of angry answers against natural methods to treat Eyes.Advantages Easy Clear Vision and Bonus Views,Personal experience ,easy clear vision scam

on Sep 15, 2014

Great blog and I love what you have to say Rivertrees Residences | Rivertrees | the rise @ oxley residences | rise @ oxley | and I think I will tweet this out to my friends so they can check it out as well.

on Oct 16, 2014

It is an excellent site about farming. There are many great contents about farm industries on this site.
Unique Custom Cardboard Boxes

Post new comment
or to use your Farm Industry News ID
What's Farm Industry News Blog?

The Farm Industry News Blog features commentary from Willie Vogt, Jodie Wehrspann, Kathy Huting, Lynn Grooms, Daryl Bridenbaugh and Jeff Ryan.

Blog Archive

Sponsored Introduction Continue on to (or wait seconds) ×